About Us

About Us

The agency was founded in 1940 by Harold Fitzgerald.† Harold was a State Farm agent for 5 years and became the leading hail insurance salesman by 1945.† The next year State Farm discontinued Hail Coverage and Harold became the only Hartford general agent south of Route 36 in Illinois.†

In 1960 James Fitzgerald, Haroldís son, joined his father at the family business. It was a time of change and growth for the insurance business as Jim and Harold grew the business into a area leader in both farm and personal insurance. Imogene, Haroldís daughter, joined the agency as well and worked from 1967 to 1992.† Marilyn Fitzgerald, Jimís wife, joined in 1975 and worked until they both retired in December of 2006.

Michael Fitzgerald, the current president of Fitzgerald Insurance, joined in the family business in 1982.† His wife Gina is an integral part of the business.

Sarah Fitzgerald, cousin to Mike, came on board in 2007 and is licensed in all lines of insurance. Carolyn Oliver is† our part-time receptionist. While not related to the Fitzgeralds, Carolyn is part of the family.† Our fourth generation, Joe Wheeler, is now part of the sales staff and is a licensed agent for your home and auto needs.



Meet the staff

Mike Fitzgerald, President

Sarah Fitzgerald, Agent

Joe Wheeler, Agent

Carolyn Oliver, Receptionist

Fitzgerald Insurance

111 E. Main St

PO Box 353

Bethany, IL 61914

Phone: (217)665-3513

Fax: (888)509-8897

E-mail: mikefitz@fitzins.com

Working with you, Fitzgerald Insurance Agency, Inc. gathers the necessary information from you and other public and insurance sources to execute the insurance market search and placement for the insurance coverage's your needs/risk exposures require. In doing so, Fitzgerald Insurance Agency, Inc. exchanges such information only with other insurance related parties that are similarly obligated under state and federal privacy laws and have in place the appropriate procedures to keep all treatments and exchanges of your information within the requirements of these laws.

We will not, under any circumstance exchange your information with any other disaffiliated third party. Please view our full privacy statement here.