Report a Claim

Report a Claim

To report a claim, follow the directions below for your company

Fitzgerald Insurance

111 E. Main St

PO Box 353

Bethany, IL 61914

Phone: (217)665-3513

Fax: (888)509-8897


Working with you, Fitzgerald Insurance Agency, Inc. gathers the necessary information from you and other public and insurance sources to execute the insurance market search and placement for the insurance coverage's your needs/risk exposures require. In doing so, Fitzgerald Insurance Agency, Inc. exchanges such information only with other insurance related parties that are similarly obligated under state and federal privacy laws and have in place the appropriate procedures to keep all treatments and exchanges of your information within the requirements of these laws.

We will not, under any circumstance exchange your information with any other disaffiliated third party. Please view our full privacy statement here.


call Alliedís toll free personal lines service center, or visit their claims page on their website



call Safecoís toll free personal lines service center, or visit their claims page on their website


Great American

create a profile and manage your account online at Great Americanís website, or call Fitzgerald Insurance



create a profile and report your claim online at Progressiveís website, or call Fitzgerald Insurance



check out Grinnell Mutualís claims page to report a windshield claim online or call their claims center


Frontier Mutual

contact our office with your Frontier Mutual claims

217-665-3513 (Fitzgerald Insurance)


call Foremostís toll free personal lines numbers, or visit their claims page on their website to submit online

800-527-3907 (all other claims)

The Climate Corp

create an account online at The Climate Corporationís website, and call us for more information

217-665-3513 (Fitzgerald Insurance)